If a prototype part is sitting next to the series production line in a corner with unclear boundaries, the auditor sees it on the first walk. Prototype protection labels show that vehicles and parts not yet unveiled are physically protected. The assessment level varies with the objective chosen: according to the ENX participant handbook, Proto parts and Proto vehicles are assessed at AL3, Test vehicles and Proto events at AL2. The physical measures below are examples; which ones apply is determined by the chosen objective and the in-scope location. Many suppliers who are strong on information security preparation get stuck on this side with security area design, visitor management and transport processes. Below we cover the physical and organizational expectations of the VDA ISA prototype protection section in process order; the technical protection of digital prototype data is the subject of a separate article.
Prototype protection scope
The prototype protection section of VDA ISA falls under five main headings: physical and environmental security, organizational requirements, handling and transport of vehicles, components and parts, test vehicles, and events and shoots. Depending on the label chosen, all or some of the headings are assessed.
| Label | Main headings |
|---|---|
| Proto parts | Physical security, organization, transport |
| Proto vehicles | Physical security, organization, transport |
| Test vehicles | Organization, test vehicles, transport |
| Proto events | Organization, events and shoots |
The table shows the general emphasis; verify which requirements are assessed under which label from the catalog version you use and ENX’s TISAX documentation. For label selection, see the article TISAX labels.
Prototype protection and customer classification go hand in hand. OEMs define their own confidentiality classes and camouflage requirements for prototypes; the naming varies from customer to customer. The catalog expects this classification to be applied, while the customer sets the content of the classes. That’s why the first job is to collect each customer’s prototype specification and combine the requirements into a single list. Without the specification, preparation is guesswork.
Physical and environmental security expectations
The basic expectation: the area where prototypes are kept is a defined security area, and both unauthorized entry and unauthorized viewing are prevented. The assessment typically looks at:
- Security concept: A written document defining the boundaries of areas, layers of protection, responsibilities and what to do in case of an incident.
- Outer perimeter and building shell: Protecting the site boundary, doors and windows against unauthorized entry and viewing from outside. Measures such as privacy film on glass surfaces, and avoiding work layouts facing windows in the prototype area.
- Access control: Only authorized people entering the security area, entries being recorded, and permissions being reviewed regularly.
- Intrusion detection: Detecting entry to the area outside working hours and passing it to a defined response chain. Connecting the alarm to a monitoring center or security unit is a common solution.
- Video recording: If cameras are used, the retention period of recordings, access permissions and compliance with personal data legislation.
Organizational requirements and confidentiality undertakings
A physical measure is only as useful as the person applying it. However solid the door, an employee who gives their badge to a colleague disables it. Expectations under the organizational heading:
- Confidentiality undertakings: Employees, temporary staff and subcontractors with access to prototypes having signed a confidentiality undertaking before access.
- Prototype protection training: Everyone with access being trained on prototype classification, the photography ban and incident reporting, and this being recorded.
- Authorization process: Approving who accesses which area and why; removing permissions on role change and leaving.
- Visitor management: Visitor registration, escort, identity checks and a confidentiality undertaking on entering the prototype area.
- Rules on taking images: A written rule and enforcement method for camera and smartphone use (leaving them at the entrance, sealing lenses, etc.).
- Use of subcontractors: Prototype work not being given to another firm without customer approval.
- Incident reporting: Reporting incidents such as a leaked prototype photo or unauthorized access to the customer within a defined time.
How training and undertaking records are evidenced in an audit is covered separately in the article training and awareness evidence.
Prototype transport and shipping
The moment a prototype leaves the security area, the risk rises. Transport measures are set according to customer requirements; typical ones:
- A closed, view-blocking vehicle or packaging.
- A handover record before and after transport, with a seal number if required.
- Not leaving the prototype unattended at interim storage and rest stops.
- A contract with the carrier that includes confidentiality and prototype protection obligations.
- Notification steps in case of loss or damage.
| Status | Typical measure |
|---|---|
| A camouflaged or unidentifiable part | Closed packaging, handover record |
| A part that clearly reveals the design | View-blocking packaging, closed vehicle, seal |
| An uncamouflaged prototype vehicle | Closed carrier, escort, customer-approved route |
The table shows the general tendency; the exact measures are set by the customer’s classification and specification.
Test drives and events
Test vehicles
Even a camouflaged test vehicle attracts attention on public roads. The catalog expects test vehicles to be used with camouflage meeting customer requirements, and drivers to follow rules of conduct. These rules usually cover choosing parking places, conditions for taking breaks with the vehicle, not leaving the vehicle unattended, reporting incidents such as noticing it being photographed, and what to do if the camouflage is damaged. The most basic evidence: written instructions to drivers and a signed training record.
Events and shoots
Presentations with prototypes, pre-trade-show preparation, and photo and film shoots each need their own security plan. For each event, the plan defines the venue, participant list, access control, rules on taking images and the management of shoot materials (raw footage, memory cards). If the event is at an external venue, the venue’s physical suitability is assessed in advance and the film crew signs a confidentiality undertaking. A memory card is the shortest route to a leak.
Gaps you may come across
- Security area mixed with production area: Prototype parts wait on the series production line in a corner with unclear boundaries. The solution is to physically separate every place where prototypes are processed and wait, or to define a temporary security area.
- Shared badge permissions: Every employee’s badge also opens the prototype area. Permissions should be narrowed by role and a review record kept.
- Cleaning and maintenance staff: External service staff enter the area without a confidentiality undertaking or training. These people have access too and must be treated that way.
- Scrap and sample management: Rejected prototype parts mix into the normal scrap flow. A controlled disposal and recording process should be defined for prototype scrap.
- Visibility in the loading area: During shipping, the prototype can be seen from outside on a ramp with the door open. The loading sequence and area layout should be planned accordingly.
Most of these gaps are a matter of process and discipline, not investment. As part of TISAX assessment preparation, an internal walk on site a few months before the assessment, checking each item by taking notes only and no photos, gives early warning. An internal walk catches findings cheaply.
Prototype area readiness checklist
- Customer prototype specifications have been collected and a combined list of requirements produced.
- Security area boundaries have been marked on the plan, and the security concept written and approved.
- Points open to viewing from outside have been checked on site.
- The badge access permission list is current and the latest review record exists.
- There’s an alarm system test record and a defined response chain.
- The retention period and access permissions for camera recordings have been set.
- Confidentiality undertakings and training records are complete for everyone with access.
- The visitor and escort process is applied, and records are kept.
- The phone and camera rule is enforced at the entrance.
- The transport instruction, handover form and logistics firm contract are ready.
- The incident reporting process is consistent with customer requirements.
Digital information relating to prototypes, such as CAD data, photos and test records, needs network separation, device management and data leakage measures; that technical side is in the article technical controls for TISAX prototype data. For the general preparation flow, see the TISAX preparation guide. If you’re planning an independent preliminary review of your prototype area against customer and TISAX expectations, you can start from the TISAX pre-assessment preparation page. For the technical implementation of camera and recording requirements in the prototype area, see our video surveillance controls for prototype areas service.
Frequently asked questions
Is a camera system mandatory in the prototype area?
The catalog doesn’t impose a specific product or technology; it expects unauthorized entry to the security area to be prevented, detected and recorded. Cameras, alarm systems and badge access are common tools for this; which combination is sufficient depends on the customer specification and the risk assessment.
Can employees’ smartphones enter the prototype area?
That’s determined by the customer’s requirements and your security concept. Common practices are leaving phones at the entrance or covering camera lenses with tamper-evident stickers. The rule must be written, checked at the entrance, and what happens in case of a violation must be defined.
Does the logistics firm transporting prototypes also need TISAX?
It depends on the customer’s requirement and the transport conditions. A subcontractor carrying prototypes is expected to show it applies measures meeting the customer’s requirements; some customers may ask the subcontractor for a suitable TISAX label for this too. Don’t give prototype work to a subcontractor without customer approval.
Does the prototype protection label cover technical IT controls?
The prototype protection module mainly contains physical and organizational requirements. Protecting CAD data, photos and test data relating to prototypes is assessed under the information security requirements; plan the two areas together.