Training and Awareness Evidence: What Is Accepted in an Audit?

Why an attendance list isn’t enough: how to keep ISO 27001 7.2 competence and 7.3 awareness evidence, a role-based training matrix, assessment and phishing simulation records.
Technical summary
Technology
ISO/IEC 27001:2022 clauses 7.2, 7.3, A.6.3, phishing simulation, LMS
Topic
The evidential value of training, competence and awareness records
Level
Beginner–intermediate
Prerequisites
  • Role and responsibility definitions
  • HR joiner and role change records
In this article8 sections

A signed attendance list shows that a person sat in the room that day. It doesn’t show they know the policy or can carry out their information security role. That’s why training records are the easiest evidence to collect in audit preparation, but the most often found weak. Below, for ISMS owners and HR teams, we separate ISO/IEC 27001’s competence and awareness requirements and explain which records actually carry evidential value in an audit.

The difference between competence and awareness requirements

ISO/IEC 27001:2022 has two separate clauses. Clause 7.2 (Competence) requires determining the competence needed by people doing work that affects information security performance, ensuring these people are competent, where applicable taking actions to acquire competence and evaluating their effectiveness, and keeping documented information as evidence of competence. Clause 7.3 (Awareness) requires everyone working on behalf of the organization to be aware of the information security policy, their contribution to the effectiveness of the ISMS and the implications of nonconformity. A.6.3 in Annex A (Information security awareness, education and training) complements these two clauses at control level.

Requirement Who it covers Strong evidence Weak evidence
7.2 Competence Roles that affect the ISMS Role definition, competence assessment, training and effectiveness record A copy of a certificate only
7.3 Awareness Everyone working on behalf of the organization Completion report, assessment result, correct answers in interview Meeting photo, signature list
A.6.3 Training Staff and relevant interested parties Annual plan, role-based content, update record An undated presentation file

This distinction shapes the evidence strategy. Awareness targets a broad audience and must be measurable. Competence is defined per role and assessed per person. Trying to evidence both with the same attendance list is a mistake you may come across.

Role-based training matrix

A training matrix shows in a single table which role takes which training, how often, and how effectiveness is measured. The auditor uses the matrix as design evidence and per-person records as operating evidence. The table below is an example starting structure:

Role Training / competence Example frequency Effectiveness measurement
All staff Policy, incident reporting, phishing On joining and yearly Test, simulation result
System and network administrators Secure configuration, privileged access, backup Yearly + on technology change Hands-on task, audit finding trend
Software developers Secure coding Yearly Code review findings
HR Joining and leaving security, personal data Yearly Process sample
Managers Risk ownership, responsibility for access approval Yearly Quality of access reviews

Each row of the matrix must be linked to the organization’s role and responsibility definitions. The managers row is more important than it looks: if the manager approving an access review doesn’t know this responsibility, the formality risk we described in the article access review evidence grows directly. For the link to physical security and onboarding controls, see the Annex A people and physical controls guide.

Beyond the attendance list: evidence of effectiveness

Clause 7.2 requires that, where actions are taken to acquire competence (where applicable), the effectiveness of those actions is evaluated. The four levels of the Kirkpatrick model widely used in training literature (reaction, learning, behavior, results) give a practical framework here. The useful levels for an ISMS are learning (tests, hands-on tasks) and behavior: incident reports coming in, phishing emails being reported, clean desk observations. A “training satisfaction survey” proves nothing on its own.

A training record with high evidential value in an audit carries these fields:

  1. The person, staff ID and role
  2. Training name and content version (if the policy was updated, was the training updated too?)
  3. Date, duration and method (classroom, online, on the job)
  4. Trainer or platform
  5. Assessment result and pass threshold
  6. Retake date in case of failure
  7. The requirement it relates to (7.2, 7.3, customer requirement)

These records are documented information; their retention periods must also be defined. You can find the retention approach by record type in the article records list and retention periods.

The training content is evidence too

Auditors sometimes open the training itself and look at the content. If the policy was updated last year but the awareness presentation still describes the old classification levels, the training is spreading wrong information however complete the attendance record is. Put training material under document control: record the version number, author, approver, last review date and the policy version it’s based on. A revision note showing the content was updated when a significant incident, a new type of threat or a customer requirement came up is the best evidence that the program is alive.

Look at test questions with the same discipline. If the same ten questions are asked in the same order every year, they’re soon memorized. Memorizing isn’t learning. Building a question pool, giving each participant a different subset and adding role-based scenario questions increases the evidential value of the assessment result.

New joiners and role changes

The auditor often tests training evidence by sampling from the HR list: a few people who joined during the period are picked, and for each the joining date, policy acceptance record and completion date of basic awareness training are requested. Run this test yourself before the audit. Compare HR’s joiner list with the training platform’s completion report and list the people who exceeded the time in the procedure; see the gap before the auditor does.

Role changes are an often-forgotten trigger. Someone moving from accounting to system administration must be reassessed against the competence requirements of the new role. Interns, temporary staff and supplier personnel working on behalf of the organization are also within the scope of 7.3. Awareness evidence for contracted staff can be obtained from the supplier; but if this obligation isn’t written in the contract, the document you ask for won’t come.

Phishing simulation and measurement records

Phishing simulation is the most direct behavior-level measure of awareness. Tools such as Attack simulation training in Microsoft Defender for Office 365, or independent platforms, report campaign results. For evidential value, the campaign’s plan–run–follow-up cycle must be recorded:

  • Annual campaign plan: frequency, target audience, scenario difficulty level.
  • Campaign report: numbers sent, clicks, credential entries and reports.
  • Follow-up training assignments and completion records.
  • The trend across campaigns and the record of it being presented to management review.

Look not only at the number of clicks but also at the number of users who reported the suspicious email; that’s what shows behavior change. Per-person results are personal data: under the proportionality principle of KVKK (Law No. 6698), access to this data should be restricted and employees should be informed about the simulation program. For the technical protection side, the guide reducing phishing risk in corporate email is a complement. For how to design the program, NIST’s SP 800-50 Rev. 1 can be used as the primary source.

The auditor testing awareness in interviews

The strongest evidence of awareness is an employee picked at random by the auditor answering questions correctly. Questions like these come up on a site walk or in process interviews: “Where do you find the information security policy?”, “What do you do when you get a suspicious email?”, “If your laptop were stolen, whom would you call first?”, “What does this document’s classification label mean?”

Memorized answers aren’t expected. The employee is expected to show they know the right behavior within their daily work. Observations such as an unlocked screen, a customer file left on a desk or an unescorted visitor answer the same question; often more clearly than a verbal answer. How process owners should prepare for interviews is covered separately in the article preparing for auditor interviews.

Pre-audit checklist

  • The role-based training matrix is current and approved.
  • Critical roles have a competence definition and a per-person assessment record.
  • Training records keep the content version and assessment result.
  • The joiner list and training completion report are reconciled.
  • Training triggers are defined for role changes and supplier personnel.
  • The plan, report and follow-up training of phishing campaigns are recorded.
  • Training effectiveness results were presented as input to management review.

To design role-based content and assessment together, see our ISMS awareness and role-based training service, and for an overall check before certification, the ISO 27001 certification audit preparation page.

Frequently asked questions

Is an online training platform’s completion report enough on its own?

It’s strong attendance evidence for awareness, but not enough on its own. The report’s coverage must be compared with the active staff list, the version of the training content must be clear and test or assessment results must also be kept. Critical roles additionally need competence evidence.

Is a certificate required as competence evidence?

No. ISO 27001 clause 7.2 requires competence on the basis of education, training or experience; a certificate is only one of these. A CV, work experience records, internal training, mentoring and on-the-job observation records can also be evidence. What decides is that the competence required for the role is defined and the person has been assessed against that definition.

Do we need to show the auditor phishing simulation results per person?

Usually not. The auditor wants to see that the campaign was planned and run, results were measured and follow-up training was given. The aggregate results report and follow-up training records are enough in most cases. Per-person results contain personal data, so access to them should be restricted and, if needed, they should be shown masked.

Within what time should new joiners complete training?

The standard doesn’t give a time; you set it in your own procedure. The common approach is completing basic awareness training before access to systems is granted or within the first weeks of work. In the audit, you show the time you wrote was met by comparing joining dates with training completion dates.

Support

Contact us for support or a discovery session on this topic.

Contact form
[email protected]

Eretek Compliance

We work with you on compliance with ISO 27001, IATF 16949, TISAX and similar standards, covering risk assessment, control design, documentation and audit preparation.

Knowledge Center

Other articles